Sabrina Carpenter just dropped her new album “Man’s Best Friend”, and it wasn’t the music that set the internet on fire. It was the cover. In the photo, she kneels in a black dress while a suited man grips her hair, and she rests a hand on his thigh. Cue the outrage. Social media split fast. Critics called it “anti-feminist” and “creepy,” while fans rushed to defend her right to be bold and sexual on her own terms.
However, this is not the first time a woman in music has been dragged for daring to blend sensuality and art. Sabrina Carpenter is not breaking new ground here, even if it feels like it. In fact, this moment looks a lot like something Carly Simon lived through almost exactly 50 years ago.
Carly Simon Faced It First
Back in 1975, Simon’s album “Playing Possum” faced similar criticism. She posed in a black negligee and boots, with her body language caught mid-motion, fist clenched, gaze direct. Sears nearly refused to sell it. Her own mother gave her a hard time. But Simon insisted it wasn’t about sex appeal. It was about self-expression.
Sabrina / IG / Carpenter later released a second cover, this time a moody black-and-white shot. It shows her leaning into the suited man again, but the tone is softer, more Hollywood glam.
Now, half a century later, Sabrina Carpenter is getting grilled with almost identical arguments. Some say she is glorifying submission. Others think she is flipping the script on male-dominated power imagery. The cover became a cultural flashpoint in seconds, with people arguing not just about art, but about what women are “allowed” to do with their own image.
Sabrina Carpenter Pushes Back
The 26-year-old “Please Please Please” hitmaker is not new to this kind of conversation. She has leaned into sex appeal before. But “Man’s Best Friend” pushes harder. The image is louder, riskier, and clearly designed to stir.
So, when people started calling it “degrading,” she didn’t back down. Instead, she fired off a response that read: “Girl, yes [I have a personality outside sex] and it is goooooood.”
She captioned it, “Approved by God.” Was it a PR move? Maybe. Was it a clever way to shut down the debate while keeping her point intact? Definitely.
Carly Simon was not surprised. When asked about Carpenter’s photo, she shrugged off the drama: “She is not doing anything outrageous. It seems tame.” That is coming from a woman who has seen decades of culture wars over female bodies. Simon even pointed to male artists like The Rolling Stones, whose “Sticky Fingers” cover featured a close-up of a man’s bulging jeans.
Sabrina / IG / Carpenter is not trying to please everyone. If anything, “Man’s Best Friend” proves she is done asking for permission.
This all circles back to one big question. Why do women still get slammed for doing what men have done for decades? When Mick Jagger leans into raw sex, he is a rock god. When Sabrina Carpenter does it, she is accused of corrupting the youth. The double standard has not changed much since Simon’s day.
Not Everyone Disliked the Cover
Online, hashtags like #LetWomenBeHorny trended. Fans praised the cover as fearless and fun. They saw it not as a cry for attention, but as a wink to every woman who’s been told she’s “too much” for embracing her desire out loud.
She knows that the moment a woman controls the frame, every album cover, outfit, and pose becomes a political statement.
Still, pushing the envelope comes at a cost. Some fans said they felt “secondhand embarrassment.” Others admitted they were not sure how to feel. But that is part of what makes the conversation stick. People are not looking away.
